News
Ugly America's Makeover
5.02.06
Cleaning Up Our Image Is Left To Us
By JoAnn Klimkiwicz
Courant Staff Writer
America, we've got a situation.
"We the People," it seems, are an arrogant and brash bunch. We are self-serving and insensitive. We are exploitive and quick to take but slow to give back. We exalt a culture of decadence and consumerism. Our social mores? Woeful.
That, at least, is the global reputation America has built, according to a worldwide survey by a nonprofit organization whose mission is to repair the United States' sullied image and regain international respect.
In its aim to overhaul this unseemly public image, the organization is tapping one of the country's most powerful, if unlikely, resources: the American traveler.
"Americans take 60 million trips outside the U.S. a year," says Keith Reinhard, president of Business for Diplomatic Action, a nonpartisan collective of business leaders. "Sixty million trips is 60 million chances to make an impression. And they can be good, or they can be bad."
To boost instances of the former, the BDA has published a World Citizens Guide for Americans to study before setting foot on foreign soil. One-part reminder to be on one's best behavior, one-part tip sheet on navigating unfamiliar cultures, it's a booklet the organization wants in the hands of all American travelers. The group is lobbying the State Department to issue one to every U.S. passport holder, but no decision is imminent. "They haven't said yes," Reinhard says. "But they haven't said no."
For now, BDA is targeting smaller segments of the population as would-be ambassadors, equipping them to present a more attractive face of America. It began with college students, a group inclined to international travel, publishing the original 60-page, passport-size guide in 2004. Now the organization is launching a condensed executive version for the business traveler, distributing it to a host of major U.S. companies this month. Next up could be a children's edition.
The executive booklet's 16 tips read in parts like a chirpy etiquette guide - "you'll never go wrong with a smile; listen at least as much as you talk," but don't mistake the effort for a lecture in minding your manners at the global dinner table, says Reinhard.
The project is about becoming better world citizens, about tempering the swell of anti-American sentiment overseas. And it's about strengthening the U.S.'s foreign and business relations, which Reinhard worries could seriously erode if these negative impressions persist.
"This is not about etiquette or Miss Manners or trying to make things more enjoyable as a traveler," explains Reinhard, also chairman of DDB Worldwide Inc, a prominent advertising agency with 206 offices in 96 countries. "This is about mobilizing American citizens to be better ambassadors of our country," because, he says, "in marketing, we know that if you do not define your brand, somebody will define it for you."
And no sleek marketing campaign can debunk the ugly American stereotype better than the grassroots business model, this veteran ad executive contends: building one's reputation moment by moment, one interaction at a time.
Enter the American tourist, the friendly soldier Reinhard has dispatched to the front lines of this campaign.
Among his organization's suggestions: Take pride in the American way, "but remember, it's not the only way." Soften boastful talk of job status and wealth - what might be standard conversation in the U.S. is considered rude in other cultures. Avoid debate on politics and religion. ("Show a willingness to understand other viewpoints.") Slow down; be mindful that most cultures aren't as hurried when they eat, talk and move as in the U.S.
And would it kill you to ditch the Bermuda shorts for a pair of dressy slacks?
The spark for the project came just after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. President Bush, and Americans at large, seemed baffled that deep disdain for the U.S. could be bubbling in pockets across the globe.
Reinhard, head of a company with offices worldwide, was familiar with the sentiment. And he worried about its long-term implications, particularly on the health of American business. He conducted a survey of his agency's 200 international offices, asking this question: If you could advise Americans on what they could do to be a better global citizen and reduce resentment toward them, what would you say?
Admittedly unscientific, the research still returned intriguing results, Reinhard says. Among the positive impressions were what one might expect: Respondents lauded America for its "can-do" spirit and cultural diversity, viewing it as a land of opportunity, a country brimming with youthful enthusiasm.
As for the negatives, the firm was able to pinpoint four root causes of U.S. resentment: the nation's public policy; the negative effects of globalization; America's pervasive popular culture; and its collective personality - all this before the U.S. invasion of Iraq. (Said one respondent, from Germany: "How can they pretend to lead the world when they don't know anything about the world?")
Our ultimate arrogance?
"The assumption that [other countries] all want to be like us. And they don't," says Reinhard. "They said, `We admire much about American life, but we also cherish our own culture. And it might be a good idea that you learn something about us'."
BDA was born soon after, teaming up with the Temerlin Advertising Institute at Southern Methodist University in Dallas to eventually create the citizen guides. A handful of students there teased apart the research information, conduct their own studies and developed the concept. With sponsorship from PepsiCo, about 200,000 guides were published and distributed to students free.
And now comes the executive edition. About 30,000 copies have been published with sponsorship from the National Business Travelers Association, which is working with Reinhard's group to court major U.S. companies. The group plans to translate the guide into a one-day workshop later this year.
Patty Alvey, director of Temerlin, knows the subject of American behavior could touch a nerve.
"We are so rarely able to stand outside ourselves ... that most U.S. citizens may not have an understanding of how the world might view them, or may not know our joyful and rowdy cultural sensibility might indeed be offensive to other cultures," she says.
According to the last Pew Global Attitudes Project, conducted last year among 16 nations in Europe, the Middle East and Asia, the U.S. received the worst favorability rating among five major leading nations, also including Germany, China, Japan and France. Only six of the 16 surveyed countries gave the U.S. a favorability rating of 50 percent or more.
"We're not saying everybody's a boor. We're certainly not saying that. The core issue is that America's image has suffered ... and this is one thing that might give every U.S. traveler a way to open up to the world and allow the world to see the really remarkable, kind, generous people that we are."
But why should Americans temper their personalities? Shouldn't we take pride in the patchwork of qualities that make us uniquely American?
Pride, yes, Alvey and Reinhard say. Foisting our values and opinions on other cultures, no.
"Would you want someone to come into your home and behave in a way that was offensive to you?" says Alvey. "When we leave this country, we are, in effect, entering other people's homes."
This is no slick public image campaign cooked up while sipping lattes in a Madison Avenue conference, Reinhard says. It's just one in a series of projects the organization is undertaking in its goal to make Americans better global citizens and improving travel and tourism to the United States.
"These aren't PR stunts. These are actions that collectively will have a really positive impact on our image."
Joann Klimkiewicz can be reached a jklimkiewicz@courant.com.
Copyright 2006, Hartford Courant
